Many sex experts recommend avoiding numbing lubes for anal Because it has such a milky, cream-like consistency, this makes for an. You can put lots of things on your body to numb it, e.g. lidocaine, but with anal sex, the question is, WHY?? Pain in the ass is not just an. Shop Spencer's for the Best Anal Lubes! Make anal sex arousing and enjoyable with our effective Anal Numbing Creams and Gels. **DISCREET SHIPPING**.